I’m overinvested in a story about people who wanted to be pirates. (Not actual pirates, but Disney “Pirates of the Caribbean” type pirates).
I don’t know these aspiring pirates personally–I learned about them when I recently watched a 2012* episode of “Bar Rescue.” I don’t usually play in the reality TV show viewing space, but I watched this with my niece during a family visit.
I don’t want to get bogged down into reviewing “Bar Rescue” or focusing on the actual folks in this episode and what happened to them during and after the show–I’m sure if you’re interested you can find anything you want to know on the internet. (I’ve definitely spent some time doing just that and will likely spend even more.)
Setting aside all the “plot” and “character” questions this episode raises, I think I got a bit obsessed with it because it made me wrestle with the idea of following a dream. The heart of the pirate bar story seems to be “Should you follow your dream or choose financial success and stability?”

Like many people, I’m a sucker for a “follow your dream” story. And my first response to those tales is an enthusiastic, “Hell YES! Follow your dream!” There are a bazillion dream pursuit stories, and for me, none are more mythic than my beloved Muppets. Kermit, Fozzie, Miss Piggy and the gang–they are all about following their dreams despite setbacks and people telling them they can’t succeed, and making good friends and heartwarming mayhem along the way. A devoted Muppet fan like myself HAS to support dream following, right?
I also just recently listened to “Actress of a Certain Age” by Jeff Hiller, a delightful and inspiring memoir about an actor who finally realizes his dream of having a substantial role in a big network TV show (HBO’s AMAZING “Somebody Somewhere”) in his late forties (an age which now seems relatively young to me). Hiller advocates the “dreams don’t have deadlines” philosophy so I feel renewed inspiration to be on Team Follow Your Dream.
But…the Bar Pirates. One thing that seemed clear from their tale as portrayed on “Bar Rescue” is they couldn’t live their dream in an economically tenable way. Am I soulless to think that they had to give up their dream and find a way to support themselves financially? Afterall, my response when I saw “Rent” all those years ago was, “I don’t feel that bad for these young starving artists, they really should all just get a job and pay their rent.”
I guess the real question isn’t “Do I think the Bar Pirates should have given up their dream?” but “Have I given up on my dream(s)?” I don’t think so–I don’t remember any burning desire to do something that I haven’t. But maybe that just means the REAL real question for me is: “Have I ever had any dreams?”
Is the only reason I’ve never given up on a dream because I haven’t had any?
Yikes, that feels bleak. So it feels like it’s important to back up for a moment and define what I mean by a “dream.” I’ve had hopes, aspirations, and goals, but I don’t think I’ve ever felt like “I MUST do THIS!” in a big picture, “this is my life’s calling or mission” sense.
In many ways I am not a flexible or adaptive person. I don’t generally go with the flow. But I think I’m flexible about my dreams. Performing is a good example of this–if you know me at all, you know I crave the spotlight. My interpretation of “spotlight” is pretty loose, though. I’ll act, sing, drum, read one of blog posts or a children’s story–basically whatever opportunity I get, I’ll take, but I don’t have my heart set on a certain path. I’m even a little uncomfortable with the very common question, “What’s your dream role?” That question makes me twitchy because I feel locked in…what if I don’t ever get that role? What about all the other roles that I don’t even know are possible that might be out there for me? So I definitely have a desire to do something rather specific–perform–but I try to be open to what that might look like.
And what does it really mean to embrace the idea that dreams don’t have deadlines? I think that only works if we’re flexible and willing to adjust what fulfilling a dream looks like, especially if a dream depends on our physical skill and abilities. Unless we are non-aging muppets (and even muppets are in some ways affected by the passage of time and societal and cultural changes) how we are able to do things can be pretty different at 25 vs. 75.
A narrative of “Dream vs. Despair” makes for compelling entertainment, but it can be a false dichotomy. Just because I’m not a Broadway star doesn’t mean I have to be miserable. If a dream is thwarted, or worse, never even dreamed, because of racism, sexism, classism, ableism, or any other type of oppression, then that is an injustice we should all fight against. But sometimes our dreams just aren’t a good fit for us, or aren’t a good fit for us anymore, so we can reimagine them.
Back to those Bar Rescue Pirates: Did they set themselves up for disappointment and failure by narrowly defining their dream and the options available to them? I’m not an expert on pirating or bar ownership, but maybe they could have had a moderately successful restaurant that wasn’t pirate-themed (without the awful corporate theme the Bar Rescue host tried to force on them) and performed as pirates at a local renaissance fair? Or regularly held a pirate role playing game where they drank fruity drinks? These are just a couple of ideas I’m throwing out there, but I think they needed to consider what it was they loved about dressing as pirates and having a bar to try and figure out if they could meet those needs in other ways.
Maybe I’m just vague and not overly ambitious when it comes to dreams. There are experiences and feelings I desire to have, but I’m open to how I’ll get there. I want to be loved, and happy, and not create too much havoc. Hopefully I’ll get a little praise and affirmation (and a few blog readers) along the way.
*https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2264672/














