At church this Sunday, I got several compliments on my western-themed costume. Folks thought it was perfect for the Dolly Parton song (“Wildflowers”) that I played percussion on. Someone even asked if I had rented it from a costume shop.
I loved the positive attention and feedback. But I wasn’t wearing a costume. I was just wearing a new dress* that I thought was a little snazzy but perfectly normal. I chose to wear it mainly because I could find it in my closet (not something I can routinely count on) and it wasn’t wrinkled (since it was new) and it had a full skirt, which I thought would be good for cajon playing (turns out the skirt got in the way a bit but it was manageable).
Now I have used a play as an excuse to buy a new dress as a costume for a play (with the intention to wear it later in my real life) or pulled something out of my own wardrobe to use for a costume…but this wasn’t one of those times. This was just me, wearing a dress.
This also reminded me of the time the cashier at Target asked me about the costume party I was going to, because I was buying glitter eyeshadow…and I wasn’t going to a costume party (yes, I blogged about that, too: https://peppersprout.blogspot.com/2016/10/glittery-eyeshadow-aspect.html). This did happen a few days before Halloween so I can see why she had costume parties on her mind, but glittery eyeshadow is just a makeup staple in my book.
I guess I shouldn’t have been surprised by people’s reaction at church to my dress, since Chad said “Wow, you’re really leaning into the theme” before we left the house when he saw what I was wearing. “What do you mean?” I asked. When he explained that he thought I was intentionally going Western for the Dolly song, I just thought “Well, Chad and I have pretty different ideas about fashion.” (When I told him I was writing this blog, he said the dress made me look like Holly Hobby, which is more prairie than Western, but I definitely loved Holly Hobby** as a kid–I even had a Holly Hobby birthday cake one year. And of course, I did watch a lot of Hee-Haw. Maybe my love of my dress is based on a deeply imprinted childhood preference for lace and ruffles.)
I did intentionally wear my cowboy hat during the song, thanks to Chad, who suggested it. At first I thought “no that’s too much” but then brought it along (and wore it only while we played the song). Chad even wore his, too (yes, we both own “cowboy” hats, although they’re just flimsy Target ones. Chad does own a more substantial one, but didn’t wear that to church).

Unfortunately, I didn’t wear my cowboy style boots, which I nixed because I didn’t think they would be as comfortable as the flats I did wear. Maybe that’s for the best…people’s heads may have metaphorically exploded if I went too Western.
But, to reiterate, even without cowboy boots and before I donned my cowboy hat many people thought I was wearing a costume, when I was just wearing what I considered a regular dress. And I love this.
What did I say when I got these “Great costume!” compliments? “Thanks!”…while trying to clarify that I was just dressed as Amy On Any Old Day (or at least one where I left the house). I could have pretended that I was intentionally theme dressing and this wasn’t my regular look, but I wanted to embrace the situation. I love that I was “dressing up” even when I wasn’t trying to.

I love when I’m being authentically quirky without any intentional affectation. I’ll take pride in bringing a little unplanned theatricality (not “drama”) to a gathering and a smile of bemusement to someone.
I just hope no one ever thinks I’m wearing a Sexy Librarian costume because everyone should know that is just ONE HUNDRED PERCENT me.
*I’ve been decadent and purchased SEVEN new dresses in the last week. I’ve been trying to reduce my carbon footprint and support of businesses with questionable ethics (and I have a serious lack of closet space), but sometimes I still indulge my clothes habit. I can only say as a slim justification that I purchased three of the dresses from a small local business and the others are “eco-friendly.” I consider all of the dresses more or less practical (meaning I can wear them to places I will actually go without too much of a production) but I’m interested to learn if there are more unexpected costume parties in my future! I did wonder if the dress I wore to our anniversary party looked like a swimsuit coverup but no one mentioned that…
**Actually, he said something more colorful about my Holly Hobby look, but you’ll have to ask me about that in person or via a direct message–we have his ministerial reputation to consider.












